There is an activity popular amongst those who consider themselves tolerant or “enlightened” that occurs at meetings and gatherings both public and private. This is is known as a “moment of silence.” It takes place at the same time as what would traditionally be a prayer. However, those demanding this moment of silence believe that a prayer to any particular god is an act of prejudice as there may well be those in attendance who worship a god other than the one to whom the majority would be praying. In their benevolence and understanding, in their supreme tolerance of others, these people choose the moment of silence as a way to show their respect for all faiths. I think this practice is at best foolish and at worst insulting.
This video should highlight the problem, but let me make it as clear as possible. There is little in the way of “respect” shown to someone’s god when you 1) don’t let them say it’s name out loud, and 2) grant equal “respect” to other gods, you know, the ones who don’t exist for the believers. All you can succeed in doing is belittling the beliefs of the devout, and this should not be surprising. After all, how other than a veiled insult can someone take the suggestion that their god, the real one(s), is the same as all the false gods that adherents to other religions think exist? It is ridiculous to think that anyone even could take such a situation any differently if they’re paying any attention at all to what’s happening.
Think about it. Say that you’re a Muslim, and you believe Allah is the One True God. What you have is a situation where the people leading the moment of silence saying both that it is appropriate for others to pray to false gods, to flaunt their status as an infidel in your face, and that you yourself should afford such behavior some measure of respect. Who are these people to demand something so absurd of someone? Of course, the same goes for an adherent to any religion that holds that it is wrong to worship false gods, that being most of them. Certainly, Christianity is one of those religions, the first one, two, or three (depending on how you count them) of the Ten Commandments dealing with that very thing. It is foolish to think that any Christian who takes the Ten Commandments seriously would be comfortable with this moment of silence that grants false gods the same respect as God. I mean, duh.
Worse, the only people who might not be upset about this, the only people who might appreciate such a situation, are the very ones for whom such a demonstration of “respect” is wholly unnecessary. That is, it is only those people who are comfortable with other people worshiping different gods, who take no offense at such activity, that would be okay with this generic “moment” in the first place. I mean, if I don’t think it’s a big deal that everyone gives respect to my god, then I don’t think it’s a big deal that everyone gives respect to my god! For that reason, this attempt at pacification and tolerance is pointless in relation to the only people for whom it might be acceptable.
Then we have the issue of non-believers and those who might believe in a god but just don’t like him. For atheists, the demand that they take a moment to show respect for nothing is just strange. What could the point of that be? Surely it can’t be to show respect for gods they don’t think exist. How insulting, how patronizing and condescending, it would be for an atheist to pat someone on the back and say, “You go ahead and pray to your imaginary friend.” Even worse, if that’s possible, would be for the individual who believes but refuses to give respect to the deity. Imagine someone who looks at the world with its various catastrophes, e.g. the floods, hurricanes, genocide, raping of babies, and the burying of women up to their necks in the sand for the purpose of crushing her skull with rocks until she is dead, out of “respect” for a god no less, and has concluded that no amount of evil could exist without a designer, an infinitely powerful fiend whose sole desire is to torment and cause suffering. That person almost certainly has no desire to show respect for that god, and yet this is exactly what this moment of silence demands of her. That’s absurdity of cosmic levels.
This demand for a moment of silence can only be made by those who are woefully ignorant or just jerks who don’t care about or respect the actual beliefs of others. Let’s cut this crap out.
*Lest there is any confusion, I do not have in mind here anything like the similarly-called “moment of silence” used as an opportunity to remember the dead at funerals and memorial services or anything of that nature.